The moves that matter in academic writing by gerald graff 1 everyone knows some young person who is impressively street smart but does poorly in school. In a simple way, it turns to be a question of street smarts vs. Professor of english and education university of illinois at chicago president, modern language association 2008. Hidden intellectualism 244 gerald graff nuclear waste 252 richard a. Graff insists that knowledge can also take the form of street smarts. Response to hidden intellectualism by gerald graff. Many academics themselves will tell you that you compromise your career if you write in. This deep automation will touch all jobs, from manual labor to knowledge work.
Reading analysis 2 they say, i say in chapter 2, her point is, of the book they say, i say, by gerald graff and cathy birkenstein the main argument is the guide to a good summary. Why video games matter tom bissell the good, the bad, and the daily show jason zinser hidden intellectualism gerald graff 16. As a child, graff always looked for a happy medium between brawn and brain. Muller the futile pursuit of the american dream 260 barbara ehrenreich everything that rises must converge 272. In gerald graffs hidden intellectualism, graff attests that intellect does not only exist in the scholarly form of thinking. A summary of hidden intellectualism by gerald graff. The authors start by giving a small thought about the art of summarizing, why people do it and why others despise this way of writing. Hidden intellectualism pedagogy duke university press. He also elaborates on his experiences in revealing his own hidden intellectualism.
He primarily focused on the way adolescents view intellectualism as a negative trait that only nerds strive for. Gerald graffs hidden intellectualism summary free essay. Cathy birkenstein is a lecturer in english at the university. The bestselling book that demystifies academic writing, they say i say, the moves that. Graff argues that street smarts are more intellectual than book smarts because they test all the parameters of intellectualism in a better way than. The article hidden intellectualism by gerald graff is adapted from his 2003 book clueless in academe. Summaryresponse for hidden intellectualism draft 1 o. Final paper of hidden intellectualism summaryresponse. This book identifies the key rhetorical moves in academic writing. There is a different form of intellectualism besides the traditional academic intellectual thought. They say i say gerald graff, cathy birkenstein, russel.
He says there are many common misconceptions about the liberal arts and lists what he believes are the seven biggest misconceptions of today. The critical reader conversation with gerald graff and cathy. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our privacy policy. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff 78 words 123. Tone logos the tone of this article sounds as if he is trying to serve a purpose. Some may say that being intellectual means being book smart, while others say that it is being street smart. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. In the essay hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, many points are argued. Chicago turabian author date citation style guide graff, gerald and cathy. Hidden intellectualism, gerald graff essay 418 words. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Coauthor of they sayi say handbook, gerald graff, analyzes in his essay hidden intellectualism that street smarts can be used for more efficient learning and can be a valuable tool to train students to get hooked on reading and writing graff 204. Especially for beginning writers, they say i say offers an excellent roadmap to the new world of academic discourse.
The book also provides templates to help students make these key. The moves that matter in academic writing fourth edition. Hidden intellectualism an excerpt from they sayi say. Graff uses his own experiences in his childhood to help form his argument.
Graff tells about his disinterest in traditional academic subjects, and. Graff insists that knowledge goes far beyond academic learning and continues into the everyday world. Graff explains that schoolsmarts can be hidden within street smarts and can be learnt through not just talking with friends, but also from the media and our surroundings, hence the. Daniel zimmerman, middlesex county college the argument of this book is importantthat there are moves to academic writing. They say i say audiobook by gerald graff, cathy birkenstein.
Many students say that it is the first book theyve found that actually helps them with writing in all disciplines. As graff describes, he felt the need to prove i was smart and the fear of a. In hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, he begins with the argument of streetsmarts versus schoolsmarts. Graff has a very strong voice and many opinions to help further his arguments.
In an entry of hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, graff believes that one can actually become intellectual if they start learning about topics they actually. Brett clark 12216 summary essay college composition and research liberal arts are not too bad in the article, the new liberal arts written by sanford j ungar, ungar talks about all of the modern misconceptions about the liberal arts degree. There must be many buried or hidden forms of intellectualism that do not get channeled into academic work but might if schools were more alert about tapping into them. What a waste, we think, that one who is so intelligent about so many things in life seems unable to apply that intelligence to. Gerald graff argues that our schools and colleges make the intellectual life. He demonstrates that while some people come across as very street smart, with knowledge on a variety of subjects, they do poorly in school and seem like they are. The moves that matter in academic writing third edition 3rd edition by gerald graff author, cathy birkenstein a. How teaching the conflicts can revitalize american education, and, most recently, clueless in academe. Hidden intellectualism an excerpt from they sayl say. This book is an attempt by an academic to look at academia from the. Automatic works cited and bibliography formatting for mla, apa and chicagoturabian citation styles. Hidden intellectualism they say i say free pdf file sharing. In your essay hidden intellectualism, you describe your introduction to. In the passage, hidden intellectualism from the book they sayi say, gerald graff talks to us about how street smarts and academic work could go hand in hand.
A response to hidden intellectualism abigail bashor. He says that if we start off by teaching students to think academically about subjects that interest them, teachers would grab their attention better and they would. The three most common ways of using i say are agreement, disagreement, and a combination of the two. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff, is an essay in which the former english professor discusses the misconceptions of the ideas of intellectualism amongst society.
He also elaborated on his own experiences in revealing his hidden intellectualism, while. He primarily focuses on the way adolescents view intellectualism as a negative trait that only nerds strive for. An analysis of hidden intellectualism by gerald graff. Historian of the profession and of the professions arguments, influential commentator and spirited critic of the educational practices that havedefined literature and composition classrooms, forceful advocate for the profession in the public spheregerald graff stands as the professions indomitable and indispensable arguerinchief. They say i say teaches students the key rhetorical moves found in persuasive writing across all. Specifically, they are designed to help students develop a way of responding to people or shaping an argument or different perspective. Read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff on welcome.
Lauren mason moved read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff from week 3 to week 2. Ti o l\ they say i say the moves that matter in academic with writing readings gerald. Part 2 i say chapter 4 chapter four introduces the i say stage to where you offer your own argument as to what they have said. Gerald graff, a professor of english and education at the university of illinois at chicago and 2008 president of the modern language association of america, has had a major impact on teachers through such books as professing literature. Graffs assertion that intellectualism can be developed and sharpened in a context outside of what we consider to be solely academic is a claim that is reasonably made and that has the potential to encourage a greater number of students to think critically. In his essay hidden intellectualism gerald graff offers a critique of the education system for overlooking the intellectual potential of those who possess unconventional street smarts. Hidden intellectualism gerald graff analysis 85 words. They say i say discusses these templates more fully, and includes useful lists of them, especially in the end of the book.
145 1199 39 63 660 1551 595 537 1232 743 1008 429 1604 136 1414 1530 1127 863 1555 783 1079 45 906 364 1033 732 640 1190 1258 109 222 603 1293 1262 423 152 1272 982 106 290 270 638 1212